Let’s talk about debt on a dairy farm (or any business, for that matter). Many have asked what constitutes a good level? Is it $3,000 debt per cow? Less than that? $5,000? Am I sunk if it’s more than that? Should I look at that EBITDA number somehow?

The answer to all of that is… it depends. Looking at quantifiable measures in relation to the earnings available and/or needed to service the debt is a good approach. Don’t discount other less tangible factors such as risk tolerance and management ability.

Financial Measures

Mechanical financial measures like coverage ratios and solvency measures paint a picture about what the debt looks like. Calculations can be done to give the analyst a sense of the cushion that exists. Some cushion is beneficial, especially when/if conditions change- like price fluctuations, inflation, expansion, unexpected breakdowns, etc. A measure like debt per cow tells you the level of debt that exists and how it’s has trended over time, but it doesn’t give the whole story. Managing $5,000 debt per cow may be fine for a farm with high profitability while it’s way too much for one with lower margins.

Debt to EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization) is a coverage ratio that has become more popular in dairy business analysis. It gives a better sense of where the cushion is and what it should be. For example, debt to EBITDA is a way to measure leverage as a way to quantify as a multiple the total debt level compared to earnings. Generally speaking, keeping that multiple 5 or under is a good measurement. If it starts getting over 5 consistently, some deeper analysis may be required. Of course, it is also tough to peg dairy business results to one year. It’s best to look at this number as a 3- or 5- year average.

Other Factors to Consider

  • Risk tolerance levels. Comfort level with risk extends to debt levels. The more averse to risk, often the more financially conservative and a debt-minimizing approach is preferable. Or, if debt must exist, conservative terms such as fixed rates and low loan-to-collateral values are used. However, fixed rates often come with a premium for off-setting market risk over time. You may end up paying more for fixed rate, over time. Again, it comes back to level of comfort and what makes the most sense for your business.
  • Management ability. Some managers are very good at juggling lots of plates, while others are best when they can focus on one, two or maybe three. The same could be said when it comes to managing debt- keeping up with payments and making sure progress is being made. Occasionally even the most profitable or most liquid business have trouble making payments. Despite the many tools available- automatic payments, automatic reminders, whatever, they just can’t organize in such a way to keep up.
  • Off-farm income. A farm with low solvency – that is higher debt-per-cow or debt-to-asset ratio (i.e., lower net worth) may be more likely to cover larger debt payments if there’s a consistent source of off-farm income- be it rental, from a job or something else. In fact, according to the 2019 ag census, 96 percent of farm households had some level of income from off-farm sources (ers.usda.gov/amber-waves).

If you’re curious where you stand when it comes to debt, please don’t wait! Contact your financial advisor today or give us a shout. We can help break it down for you.